Showing posts with label Kant. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Kant. Show all posts

April 15, 2010

Kant's Philosophy of Science: Part II: Opus Postumum

During the nearly twenty years between The Metaphysical Foundations of Natural Science (1786) and his death (1804), Kant was as prolific as ever, writing treatises on practical reason (1788), judgement (1790), religion (1793), peace (1795), morals (1797), and logic (1800). Despite this incredible outpouring of analysis and thought ostensibly unrelated to science, Kant's interest in physics never waned; in fact, he was hard at work on his unfinished magnum opus designed to inform the transition between philosophy--Metaphysical Foundations--and physics. This astounding collection of notes, drafts, and drawings, collectively referred to as the Opus Postumum, remained unpublished for more than a century, deemed un-editable, fragmentary, and, at times, vague--but recent scholarship has unearthed correspondence between Kant and his closest comrades, with whom Kant shared detail about his final major critical work. Paul Guyer, in his introduction to the 1993 translation of the Opus Postumum, quotes Kant from a letter he wrote to his apprentice, Kiesewetter, in the early 1790s: "The transition from The Metaphysical Foundations of Natural Science to physics must not be left out of the system...with that work the task of the critical philosophy will be completed and a gap that now stands open will be filled." Another former pupil, R. B. Jachmann, wrote of this work being "the keystone of his entire system...which was to demonstrate conclusively the tenability and real applicability of his philosophy".

Kant retired from teaching in 1796, and spent his final decade working intensely on this manuscript. Despite his immense dedication for the project, he had occasional doubts in regards to its viability as a text--partially because his strength was waning, and he feared dying before he was able to edit the completed work to his satisfaction. Unfortunately, Kant's executor--clearly lacking understanding about a writer's process--took Kant's vacillation seriously enough to undermine the work, and unenthusiastically presented it to academic colleagues. The dismal result of this mismanagement was the disappearance of the text for fifty years. Guyer details the story of the manuscript's emergence and subsequent publication, including the nearly impossible task of organizing, interpreting, and translating the wealth of pages that comprise the modern version of the Opus. (I've quoted here from the Cambridge edition.)

History aside, the Opus Postumum is an astonishing work, with electrifying insight into physics, indicative of Kant's genius as a logician, but also momentous as an extension, and perhaps clarification and development, of his earlier metaphysical work. He continues his exploration of matter theory; constructs a definition of the concept of relation; discusses the science of nature, and the mechanical formation of the cosmos; discerns the subtleties of time, matter, and mass. Much too much to go into here, but it's well worth a look. After dozens of decades of obscurity, the whole collection of pages can now be purchased at Amazon for a mere $30.

I'll leave you with a fragment of text from an early leaf, what Kant may have considered a summation or notes in a margin, but what I'll call a poem:

Physics itself does not contain
a further transition from merely mechanical
to organic nature founded on the concept of purpose
which transition, and according to which causal laws these
purposes could be explained, exceeds the insights
of human reason
because physics itself here makes a leap, namely to
a nature which can be thought possible only through purposes
for no bridge is placed for us
to reach from one bank
to the other.

March 16, 2009

Kant's Philosophy of Science: Part I

Long before Critique of Pure Reason marked his advent to the world philosophical stage, Immanuel Kant was busy pondering the great problems of science and physics. In his work Universal Natural History and Theory of the Heavens (1755), he deduced the formation of the solar system, resulting in the Kant-Laplace nebular hypothesis; in Physical Monadology (1756) he theorized that substances fill space not by simply existing, but because of teeming sub-particle "spheres of activity" resulting from interactions between attractive and repulsive forces--sound familiar? What's so fascinating about Kant's approach to such complex and resounding issues is his unrelenting metaphysical approach: everything he analyzed was subject to the filter "how does human interpretation affect it?"

Take Newton and Liebnitz, two fellow natural philosophers: both had ideas about the solar system and its makeup, origin, and formation, but with one important difference: Newton succumbed to the idea that, because of its simplistic elegance, the fact that the planets orbited in precisely the same plane was the result of a divine creator; Kant, despite his own notions of God (more on that in a minute), pursued explanation via Liebnitzian mechanical natural law, and succeeded. According to Michael Friedman (who also wrote Kant and the Exact Sciences) in his 2004 introduction to Kant's Metaphysical Foundations of Natural Science (1786), "Kant's conception in the Physical Monadology is an early example of a "dynamical theory of matter," according to which the basic properties of solidity and inpenetrability are not taken as primitive and self-explanatory, but are rather viewed as dervied from an interplay of forces -- here, more specifically, the two fundamental forces of attraction and repulsion, which together determine a limit or boundary beyond which repulsion (and thus inpenetrability) is no longer effective and attraction (representing Newtonian gravitation) then takes over unhindered. This kind of theory exerted a powerful influence in the later part of the eighteenth century, in the work of such thinkers as Boscovich and Priestley, for example, and it can approproately be viewed as an anticipation, of sorts, of the field-theoretic approach to physics developed in the nineteenth century, beginning with the work of Farraday and culminating in Maxwell's theory of electricity and magnetism. In this sense, Kant's own contributions to a dynamical theory of matter had a significant impact on the development of natural science itself, quite apart from the original more metaphysical setting within which it was first articulated."

Back to theology, and the way an eighteenth-century intellect managed to rectify it with advanced scientific and mathematical philosophy, something that most modern-day thinkers rarely do (perhaps that's one more identity to throw at post-modernism: agnostic indifference. Despite his theism, Kant can certainly be given credit for accelerating this movement with Critique of Pure Reason, which famously criticizes the three traditional arguments for God). First, Kant dismissed the Cartesian notion that a perfect being can be deduced from a concept as such--that just because we conceptualize life, nature, reason, or consciousness to be complex beyond organic creation doesn't mean it has to be supernatural. Or, in his terms, "Existence is not a predicate." Second, Kant saw as problematic the Liebnitzian philosophical system as being based on mathematics, a science he felt was confined by human interpretation. Math, like all concepts--regardless of their efficacy--is man-made. Remarkably reinforced by natural physical laws: yes; theoretically accurate to a seemingly impossible degree: yes. Beyond all fallibility, of course not: mankind is incapable of approaching any science as outside our spehere of existence, which makes it moot from an omniscient perspective. Yet, Kant proposed that the infinite symmetry and wonder of nature is inherent to the laws of nature itself, not of an omnitpotent God.

So, a new theistic proof is necessary, and Kant delivers, concluding that dialectical reason has its limits, and in accepting that, man accepts something greater than self. Thus, God becomes reason.

If I can extrapolate: God is reason; reason is consciousness; consiousness is matter; matter is energy; energy is God. Let's rid ourselves of this Bible-based vengeful, judgemental, and misguided overlord premise, hmm? It just makes people crazy.